The tree looked clean on the deck. It wasn't clean where it mattered.
By the end of week one, you've got a first cut: the core question at the top, five or six branches under it, a hypothesis pinned to each. It presents well. Clean indentation, tidy boxes, the kind of structure that gets a nod in the kickoff.
Then someone actually pulls on it. Branch two and branch four turn out to cover the same ground, worded differently enough that nobody caught it while building the deck. One hypothesis has no evidence attached at all, so nobody can say what data would prove or kill it. Two branches got merged onto one slide for space, and the logic connecting them quietly disappeared.
“Where's the evidence for branch three?”
The tree wasn't wrong. It just wasn't finished, and a slide doesn't show you the gaps. It only shows you what's already there.
THE FOUR PLACES ISSUE TREE LOGIC BREAKS DOWN
Branches
In the deck. Overlap hides behind clean indentation.
Hypotheses
Pinned to a box. Nobody checks whether they're actually testable.
Evidence needs
In a separate workplan, disconnected from the branch that needs them.
MECE check
Run once, on a whiteboard, week one. Never rerun once branches move.
On one canvas, those four pieces stop living apart. Branches sit next to the hypotheses they're testing and the evidence each one needs, so a gap is visible the moment it opens, not three weeks later in front of the client.
When two branches overlap, you see it before an associate spends two days pulling data for a question the tree has, somewhere else, effectively already answered.
The issue tree stops being a slide the team built once and becomes the working logic the whole engagement runs on.
This is problem structuring for engagements where the analysis is only as good as the underlying question. A tree that looks MECE and a tree that is MECE are two different objects, and the gap between them usually surfaces in front of the client, not in the team room. Mindomo keeps the structure alive past the first draft, so branches, hypotheses, and evidence needs move together instead of quietly drifting apart the moment the deck gets built.